Redmond operating system smack-down
Windows 10 has been out for over a year and has just recently
seen the Anniversary Update land on users' desktops. The free upgrade
offer has all but finished (there are still some ways to get it free if
you have accessibility issues). Windows 10 is great, especially when
compared to its two immediate predecessors, Windows 8.1 and 7, as our
blow-by-blow head-to-head comparison shows.
Support cut-off date
Every operating system has its life cycle and will one day be cut off
from updates entirely, left abandoned and open to security
vulnerabilities that won't be fixed unless you're on a bespoke support
contract. As we saw with Windows XP last year, the support deadline
comes up quickly and it's important to have your affairs in order and a
plan to switch ready to go. Luckily for all three of our operating
systems here, you have several years before you'll even need to think
about switching away from them. The extended support cut-off dates for
Windows are as follows:
Windows 7 Service Pack 1: January 14th, 2020
Windows 8.1: January 10th, 2023
Windows 10: October 14th, 2025
Winner: Windows 10
This comes as no surprise - Windows 10 makes the most sense if you
want the most cost-effective way of receiving free updates for the next
decade.
User interface for desktops and laptops
Windows 7 certainly set the benchmark for a relatively consistent and
understandable user interface, although its key strength now is its
familiarity. You know where to find things, you know what sort of
results you're going to get from the Start Menu search bar and you
understand the oddities of Windows Explorer, Task Manager and Control
Panel.
This familiarity is an asset compared to Windows 8.1. Microsoft's
huge push for touchscreen devices and tablets left desktop users feeling
not only abandoned, but hugely confused. Hitting the Start button to
search for an app or file left you with a massive full-screen Start
screen that made little sense when it was first introduced in Windows 8
in 2012 and it still feels jarring today.
Windows 10 strikes a better balance here, with its Continuum mode
neatly morphing the compact Start menu into a bigger, touch-friendly
Start screen as needed. The Start menu’s links to the newly tweaked File
Explorer as well as lists of recently used apps and your pinned folders
are all huge plus points.
The Start menu in Windows 10 has undergone a few changes since its
own release. With the advent of the Anniversary update, it has three
columns in the Start Menu with All Apps always visible.
Windows 10 holds a small advantage up to this point, then, and that's
before you even consider the hugely improved window management system.
If you're someone who likes to multitask, Windows 10 has you covered.
Windows 8.1 has better multi-monitor support than Windows 7. Unlike
7, 8.1 has a taskbar on each screen showing only those apps running on
that screen. Plus each monitor can have its own distinct wallpaper. and
each screen given its own customisable wallpaper.
Windows 10 builds on this foundation, adding an improved version of
Windows Snap so you can easily organise your windows in just a couple of
clicks. Answering the prayers of those of us with multiple monitors
running at different resolutions, there are now settings for scaling
text and the UI on a per-monitor basis.
Even if you only have one display, such as when you're using a laptop
on the move, Windows 10 now has built-in multiple desktops (like Ubuntu
and Mac OS X), so juggling lots of windows and tasks is still easier
than ever.
Winner: Windows 10
There's no question Windows 10 needed to make some serious
improvements for desktop and laptop users, and Microsoft has delivered.
Multitasking has never been easier, meaning it's by far the best choice.
User interface for tablets
Windows 7 only has the most basic interface elements and
optimisations for touchscreens, which allowed the iPad and iOS to
dominate the market for tablets. This led to the radically improved
touchscreen interface in Windows 8, but it alienated a lot of people as
it had so few accommodations for keyboard and mouse users.
Windows 8.1 added a few tweaks, nips and tucks, such as the ability
to run Modern UI apps in a resizable window, but its display scaling
problems made usable high-resolution Windows 8.1 tablets a near
impossibility.
Windows 10, while not perfect, is a big improvement. An improved
touchscreen gesture allows you to flick between applications quickly and
easily than before. If you have a hybrid device and dock it to a
keyboard, Windows 10 should recognise this change of state and switch
back to its touchpad-friendly desktop mode thanks to Continuum mode,
although whether this will work on your device will depend on whether
its manufacturers has released drivers that support this.
Windows 10 Anniversary Update features a new Ink Workspace that puts
pen-based apps in their own panel at the bottom-right corner. The new
apps boast Screen Sketch, Sketchpad and Sticky Notes. The latter
integrating with its cloud services. Pen devices should work well with
Windows 10 with great Ink support.
Winner: Windows 10
If you have a tablet or a tablet/laptop hybrid, Windows 10 is your
best bet. With features catering well for both, you'll work more
efficiently that you could on Windows 8.1 or Windows 7.
Security
Windows 7 and 8.1 are by no means insecure operating systems; but
Windows 10 has moved both home and enterprise security along
significantly, both in terms of local device security and the security
of your online services, too.
First of all, there's Windows Hello, which lets you log-in using a
fingerprint, face or iris scan instead of a password. While computers
with the necessary biometric scanning hardware built-in are currently
uncommon, we’re helpful that more will become available quickly given
that Hello is built into Windows 10 from the very start.
There's also Passport, a single sign-in service for consumers that
allows Windows to authenticate with websites on your behalf without you
having to type in a password. This service hooks into Windows Hello,
using your biometric scan or a PIN code to verify that you are the
person you claim to be. This means you'll use your password less,
meaning it'll become much more difficult for hackers to compromise
online accounts with stolen passwords. It's not currently supported that
widely, but if it takes off, Passport could massively boost security on
your online services. As yet, though, Passport and Hello are unproven
and very much fledgling technologies.
IT managers will appreciate the ability to organise
Enterprise-licenced PCs into circles and choose when updates are applied
- great for making sure you don't disrupt your users' work. This also
means that Microsoft's new strategy of releasing frequent, individual
updates instead of bundling them into Patch Tuesdays or Service Packs
won't have a big impact on your office's productivity, as you can delay
non-critical updates for up to 90 days if you're on Microsoft's Current
Business Branch of support.
You also get Enterprise Data Protection, the ability to sign in with
an Azure ID and the ability to set up a company-wide app store.
Winner: Windows 10
Unsurprisingly, Microsoft's latest operating system has the most
advanced security features of the operating systems here. It’s good for
both consumers and IT managers.
Performance
While anecdotally we have heard of PCs running a lot quicker having
been upgraded from Windows 8.1 to Windows 10, actual performance
benchmarks on our test PC with 8GB of memory and an Intel Core i5 4690K
processor show no difference.
More important is the addition of DirectX 12 support, a low-level
graphics API designed to increase 3D graphics performance with lower
overheads while giving developers more control over how hardware is
used. This is most important for gamers though as most professional 3D
graphics software relies on the competing OpenGL API instead. Although
it’s still very early days for DirectX 12 with few titles currently
taking advantage of it, if you're looking for the best 3D gaming
performance available the Windows 10 is likely your best bet as DirectX
12 won’t be available for Windows 8.1 or 7.
Winner: Windows 10
Again, no surprises here; with no penalty in performance and DirectX 12, Windows 10 is an easy choice
Search
Search has become ever more important in operating systems, as file
and folder hierarchies have become less important and searching for a
specific filename has become a popular way of finding important files –
especially amidst messy desktops and haphazardly organised Documents
folders.
Windows 7 had a terrific search function built in the Start Menu,
finding files and folders on network shares as well as those stored
locally. It wasn’t perfect, especially if you needed to refine your
search results, but it was useful enough that we were surprised that
Windows 8 abandoned this simultaneous search ability. It also adopted a
more fiddly Start screen-based search interface and integrated web
search results from Bing and app store suggestions. These superfluous
additions were far of an annoyance than a convenience.
Windows 10 searches still hook into the Bing search engine and also
look for apps in the Windows Store. Even more annoyingly these results
are placed ahead of search results for installed apps, files and folders
with no option to change this order. Amazingly, the ability to search
your computer and network shares simultaneously is still missing.
However, you can at least easily perform more advanced searches from
the Start Menu by clicking on the My Stuff button. This lets you filter
by relevance or date, and can also narrow down your search to specific
file types including documents, photos, music and settings.
Windows 10 also includes Cortana, the personal assistant feature from
Windows Phone. This has become a major part of Windows 10 doing double
duty as a web search and a Start Menu/Windows search. Plus the ability
to search by voice is both impressive in its accurate transcription and
in its usefulness for the differently abled.
Winner: Tie
The improved advanced search features in Windows 10 are very welcome,
but its insistence on prioritising web search and app store results
isn’t. Windows 7 still holds a place in our hearts for its quick, simple
search results and network integration.
Verdict - which version of Windows is right for you?
Windows 8 had the unintended side effect of making people
significantly more attached to Windows 7 than ever before. It was a
happy medium sitting between the Vista mess and the Windows 8 Start
screen nightmare.
However, the time is right to move on. If you're still on Windows 7,
you can safely upgrade without fear of losing the things you loved most
about that OS and Windows 10 is certainly an improvement over Windows
8.1.
Source: http://www.itpro.co.uk/operating-systems/25101/windows-10-vs-windows-81-vs-windows-7-microsoft-os-head-to-head-1
Footnote: Drivers
One
area not mentioned is the number of drivers Windows 10 offers. From my
experience, Windows 10 has better and a more comprehensive library of
drivers than either Win7 or Win8.1. In prior windows versions I had to
search for motherboard discs to find the correct video, sound, and
networking drivers. Installing Windows 10, I did not have these issues.
Source: http://www.itpro.co.uk/operating-systems/25101/windows-10-vs-windows-81-vs-windows-7-microsoft-os-head-to-head-1
